Why did Wegmans recall its Semi-Sweet chocolate Nonpareils? Reasons explained

Wegmans Food Markets has decided to pull its Semi-Sweet Chocolate Nonpareils from shelves because they contain milk, which was not mentioned on the label. This move comes after the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) pointed out that milk was present in the product but not listed as an ingredient. Mellace Family Brands California, Inc., a company in Warren, Ohio, made these chocolate candies.

The problem happened because of a short-term glitch in how the supplier makes the product, which led to milk ending up in the mix by accident. The inclusion of milk in a product labeled "semi-sweet" without mentioning milk creates a danger for people allergic or sensitive to milk. The FDA warns that such individuals might face severe or fatal reactions if they consume the product:

"The recall was initiated after it was discovered that Wegmans Semi-Sweet Chocolate Nonpareils contained a milk allergen and was distributed in packaging that did not reveal the presence of milk," according to the FDA notice. "(A) subsequent investigation indicates the problem was caused by a temporary breakdown in the suppliers’ manufacturing process. People who have an allergy or severe sensitivity to milk run the risk of serious or life-threatening allergic reaction if they consume this product."

Although no harmful health effects have been reported as of July 3, authorities are asking affected customers to take the recall.

Wegmans issues recall: Affected products, states, and customer instructions

The recall covers products sold in see-through plastic containers at Wegmans stores in several U.S. states, including New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Delaware, Maryland, Massachusetts, Virginia, and North Carolina. The product was also sent to Washington D.C.

Customers can identify the affected items using the following details:

• UPC: 0 77890 49787 6
• SCC: 10077890497873

The Lot Numbers and Best By Dates:

• 55021 – December 28, 2025
• 55031 – December 29, 2025
• 55491 – February 13, 2026
• 55501 – February 14, 2026
• 56061 – April 11, 2026
• 56071 – April 12, 2026

Wegmans has informed customers who bought these batches to stop using them and return them to the store to get a full refund. The company shared the recall notice online in addition to putting up notices in stores. They are also keeping people updated through customer service.

The manufacturer reported the undeclared allergen to the FDA on June 25. The FDA is still keeping an eye on this and has asked consumers, those with allergies, to check product labels even from brands they trust.