Netflix’s Queer Eye seems like an awkward fit in these "woke" times

The Daily Beast

Looking back at the original Queer Eye for the Straight Guy, the five stars had — with the exception of Carson Kressley — personalities that “were all pretty muted and down-to-earth,” says Kevin Fallon. “I had prepared myself for a cacophony of men in a**less chaps snapping their fingers and shouting ‘fierce’ every three seconds; in reality, they were certainly quippy, but also just normal, competent guys.” In the Netflix Queer Eye, “the men in the reboot are appealingly well-intentioned, but hardly as calibrated,” he says. The problem, he adds, is that the new Fab Five “subscribe to the modern reality-TV idea that LOUDER! IS! BETTER! At some point, this grating big-ness became the default for anyone looking to make an impression on reality TV, but it generally has the effect of seeming artificial and hollow. It’s a shame, because the encounters the hosts have with the men whose lifestyles they’re meant to rehab are, once the hysteria settles, quite genuine. Beautiful, even.”

ALSO:

• This is a kinder, gentler Queer Eye where the cattiness has been toned down
• The Atlanta-set reboot seems recalibrated “slightly but emphatically… for the Trump era”
• Watch the original Queer Eye cast meet their successors
• The original Queer Eye stars reflect on the impact they made in 2003
• Thanks to commercial-free Netflix, the new Queer Eye has time to delve deeper with each guy