Agatha All Along could be hiding a major twist—and this theory explains how it might play out

Agatha All Along, the Disney+ spin‑off led by Kathryn Hahn’s delightfully devious witch, hooks viewers with its eerie “Witches’ Road,” a treacherous path promising power to whoever completes its ballad‑driven trials. From the moment Agatha Harkness invites covens to summoning ceremonies, fans have debated the road’s true nature, especially after the finale revealed it was a mirage born of Billy Maximoff’s panic‑fueled chaos magic.

Yet amidst all the official reveals, a darker theory has taken root online: what if Agatha All Along could be hiding a major twist by lying about ever walking the Witches’ Road—an idea that should change everything viewers thought they knew about her long game and give fresh context to how it might play out.

Agatha’s grand deception: The road that never was

Many fans argue that Agatha fabricated the entire Witches’ Road myth to entrap rival witches and harvest their powers. According to a detailed Reddit theory, Agatha composed the road’s deadly ballad centuries ago alongside her son Nicholas Scratch, then spread rumors that only passage along the enchanted trail could restore lost magic.

In reality, no such path existed—coven initiates were lured into deadly traps orchestrated by Agatha herself, ensuring she absorbed their mystical energies upon their demise. Some theorists note that this scheme would fit Agatha’s modus operandi of long‑con cons, painting her as a centuries‑old swindler rather than a benevolent mentor.

The Ringer’s post‑finale analysis goes further, suggesting that the Witches’ Road ballad was Agatha’s creation, designed to entice witches into following choreography that weakened their defenses, rendering them easy prey. If true, this twist reframes Agatha not as a reluctant guide but as the series’ ultimate trickster.

​

How this theory explains the ultimate twist of Agatha All Along

Building on the deception theory, critics from argue that the real twist isn’t Billy’s accident‑born road at all but Agatha’s centuries‑long hustle finally unraveling in plain sight. Video essays highlight moments where Agatha subtly mocks coven leaders off‑camera, hinting she never intended to share power but to feast on it. Entertainment Weekly’s showrunner insight confirms that Agatha manipulated Billy into manifesting his own powers, making the Witches’ Road a “long con” orchestrated by her from the shadows.

Online think pieces note that Agatha’s ghost‑mentor twist in the finale only deepens this con: she remains close to Billy to ensure his naiveté continues fueling her schemes. This layered deception theory predicts that future episodes of Agatha All Along—or even other MCU series like Vision Quest—will peel back more of Agatha’s lies, revealing that every trial and triumph along the road was scripted to serve her agenda. In this light, the show transforms from a simple survival quest into a masterclass in manipulation worthy of its witchy protagonist.

​

Whether Agatha All Along really spun the Witches’ Road saga as her greatest con or simply rode Billy’s magic wave, this theory casts every scene in a new shade of betrayal and brilliance. If true, the ultimate twist proves that in this show, deception is the most powerful spell of all.

Jasmine is a journalist for Primetimer

She graduated with a B.A. in English Literature from Sophia College in Mumbai, where she had the unique opportunity to publish research in social science and media.

Jasmine holds more than three years of experience including an ex-Founder's role at a digital marketing agency called 'Very Weird'. Additionally, she also had stints as a journalist at GrowMeOrganic and Scatter Content. She also worked in the Social Media Management team for beauty and wellness brands, Green Maven and Yoga House Mumbai.

Jasmine is a strict follower of ethics in journalism and stays updated with industry developments in order to improve her craft. She is committed to presenting diverse perspectives, which enriches her storytelling and enhances the relevance of her articles in today’s dynamic media landscape.